Proposing at the Lightner Courtyard vs. the Lightner Fountain
If you’re dreaming of a romantic proposal in St. Augustine, the Lightner Museum offers two incredible options — the Lightner Courtyard and the Lightner Fountain. As a proposal photographer who has captured countless love stories here (I seriously live there at this point), I’ve seen the magic (and a few challenges) of both spots. Here’s a side-by-side comparison to help you decide which one is right for you.
To hire me as your proposal photographer, you can find more info here: https://phavyphotos.com/proposal-photography
Lightner Courtyard Proposal Photos
Pros:
- Exclusive, private feel – The courtyard is blocked off from the public, so you won’t have random onlookers in your photos.
- Charming architecture – Features a picturesque bridge, lush landscaping, and elegant stone details that photograph beautifully.
- Romantic atmosphere – Surrounded by historic Spanish architecture, the courtyard feels intimate and timeless.
- Consistent lighting – The courtyard’s walls and greenery offer even, flattering light at most times of the day.
Cons:
- Permit fee required – The Lightner Museum charges a $250 photography permit fee.
- Restricted hours – Access is limited to 9 a.m. – 5 p.m. on weekdays, with even more limited weekend availability.
- Advance scheduling – Because it’s a popular spot, you’ll need to reserve well in advance to secure your time.
- Less flexibility for spontaneity – Last-minute proposals can be tricky due to the required booking and permit process.
Lightner Fountain Proposal Photos
Pros:
- No permit fees – This public space is free to use for photography.
- Available anytime – You can propose at sunrise, sunset, or even under the romantic glow of city lights at night.
- Beautiful backdrop – The fountain, surrounded by palm trees and historic architecture, creates a grand and iconic St. Augustine look.
- Easier to plan last-minute – Since no permit is required, it’s perfect for surprise proposals on short notice.
Cons:
- Not private – The fountain area is open to the public, so there’s a chance of people walking in the background.
- Possible distractions – Street noise, passing cars, and tourists may be present.
- Lighting challenges – Midday sun can be harsh, so timing around golden hour is best for the most flattering photos.
Which Should You Choose?
If you want privacy, elegance, and a truly intimate setting, the Lightner Courtyard is worth the extra planning and permit cost. If you’re looking for flexibility, zero permit fees, and the freedom to propose anytime, the Lightner Fountain is a wonderful choice.
Either way, both spots are undeniably beautiful for proposing — and with the right photographer (hi, that’s me!), your proposal will be captured with emotion, artistry, and the timeless beauty St. Augustine is known for.
Phavy Photography (phavyphotos.com)
St. Augustine Proposal Photographer
E-mail: contact@phavyphotos.com
Phone: 904-228-1350
If you would like to inquire for proposal photography in St. Augustine, please fill out the inquiry form below
